Lately I’ve been thinking about why it’s so hard to keep up-to-date with messages. I have questions:
I’ve got messages from days ago that I’ve yet to read much less respond to. Why haven’t I?
Is something wrong with me?
Is this a Gen Z thing? Why?
Why doesn’t it apply to everyone?
Why can’t we just text them back???
I dove deeper into my shower thoughts in this YouTube video, talking about the digital and stimulation overload, the generational component to responding, and the “identity” connection.
I don’t have the exact right answer.
– Reasons for not responding
I don’t have full and complete information.
I don’t have the response they want.
I don’t feel like it.
I anticipate a lengthy follow-up conversation.
It feels like a lot.
I left the message unread too long and now it doesn’t apply.
Digital Fatigue & Stimulation Overload
Pretend for a second it’s 2005. You pick up your phone to 1. text someone, 2. call someone, or 3. check the time. There’s nothing else to do on your phone. Phones weren’t carried from room to room.
Compare that to 2026. Think about our relationships with our phones: We spend most of our days watching, reading, or playing games on our phones. I don’t know about you, but I’m tired. The amount of content consumed is taxing for the brain.
Our phones are the reason we can be “always on” and reachable, even when we don’t want to be. When I reach for my phone to take a break, escape, distract myself and watch some YouTube videos, I’m not exactly getting that break. I can still be reached on the device I’m using to escape. There’s no separation between communicating and consuming, and I think that makes it that much harder to respond. While we may have the capability to respond to a text message, we’re arguably too fatigued to have a comfortable capacity to respond. More on that later.
Across Generations
This ‘affliction’ isn’t exclusive to Gen Z, but because Gen Z is the first generation to grow up with a phone in hand (from birth or starting around 10 years old), it hits us the hardest. Digital life is a huge part of our identity.
According to an article by the Vervo app company (an app that helps write responses to text messages), “Being a digital native doesn’t make texting easier. It makes it harder… Gen Z built identity and social skills on the screen. Which means the screen isn’t supplementary — it’s foundational. And when the foundation is digital, every digital interaction carries the weight of identity itself.”
If you’ve noticed the response behaviors of generations older than Gen Z, you may notice their lack of overthinking. There is less pressure for them to construct a perfect response, because the screen is, using the words from the Vervo article, supplementary rather than foundational.
Problems arise when generations communicate with Gen Z. There’s a misconception that being on your phone all the time means you should be obligated to reply right away. But being capable of doing something is not the same thing as having the capacity.
Identity & Perfectionism
In The Sunday Times article “Why don’t they text back?,” Gen Z member Yasmin Choudhury writes, “It’s actually because we’re always on our phones that we often don’t reply to messages.”
She notes, “If I get a message from a distant relative, I have to psyche myself up to reply because I want to get the tone just right. It means I delay texting back until I have time to craft a balanced response. The danger, of course, is that I never actually get round to it.”
With digital communication as a large part of a Gen Z person’s identity, there’s a higher standard to a response. A response should be thoughtfully crafted, contain all the information and come across in the intended tone. After all, anything we say can be screenshotted and shared.
Consequences
Whether the long response time is due to anxiety, overthinking and perfectionism, or something else, there are relational impacts. I’m guilty of having read a message so late that it no longer applies or missing things because of it.
Rifts can form in relationships as resentment builds. If I know I’m not going to hear back from a person in a timely manner, I may choose not to reach out to them with certain things. That’s not necessarily a bad thing, but I try not to be too much of a “flaky communicator” myself.
Another impact to consider is how our response time impacts others’ expectations of our future responses. I think about this topic a lot and tend to be in two camps. The first: what’s wrong with me? Why can’t I just read messages and respond like a “normal person”? The second is the part of me that is working to slow down and not treat everything as urgent. I want to slow down and resist urgency, but I feel guilty when doing so. I don’t want to be known as a flaky communicator, but I also don’t want to be perceived as reachable at all times or as someone who’s an instant-replier. I want a life!
Hmm…
Tools
Let’s talk tools. I’ll admit I spend a bit more time explaining these in my YouTube video, so feel free to give that a watch too.
The balancing act
How can we be respectful by replying in a timely manner, but not set a precedent that we’re “always on” in a way that others feel they’re entitled to an instant response?
What does saying no have to do with it?
Remember resentment? I’d argue more resentment forms from lack of communication (or lack of timely communication) than saying no in a timely manner.
Sherlock
Are there specific people, content areas, methods of communication, or times of the day or week where you find it harder to respond?
A note on boundaries
You can choose your boundaries… but you should probably communicate them. Maybe you’re too tired to respond after 6 p.m. on a weeknight. Tell people that. Tell them not to expect a response during your quiet hours. Tell them the best time or way to reach you in a given week.
What is your responsibility?
Two things can be true: we can set boundaries, and we don’t always get to pick and choose when to reply. Sometimes we must even if we don’t feel like it.
The nature of being a human means having responsibilities like family and work. If you’ve committed to a certain role (e.g. you’re an employee, a friend, or a part-time volunteer), you have to live up to the level of response required.
A final note from, unfortunately, an AI-driven app
A slow reply doesn’t mean you’re unlovable.
And, it’s not that serious.
P.S. in case we haven’t met…
youseemnormal is a mental health platform run by a 26-year-old (hello!) who… well, seems normal. Turns out, my roommate is mental illness. Actually more like my unborn, and non-conceived baby. Because it’s like, inside of me. This is getting weird already.
Topics of focus: self-awareness (we love it), mood, anger management, perfectionism (and obsessive compulsive personality disorder), relationships & boundaries.
Leave me a comment!